i think most of the servo noise volume difference is very small. i think its more of a frequency difference than a volume thing. but its very slight difference in the hiss ( no problems with crosstalk on high tbw settings on both that is fine)
back to driving doing a stint with the mercedes amg now @ nurburgring gp i will switch firmware halfway and continue testing in that same online session
Hi Guys!
I tested the new firmware with my Lenze setup and here are the learnings:
from tat short testing I can say that the new version seems to be ok. that reconnection thing doesnât really matter for me.
after work I will do a bit mre testing with iracing and perhaps with assetto as well.
bests
szabolcs
The reconnection issue is known issue if you use 0.9.0. It will be fixed at some point.
Back from force feedback testing. the feedback is virtually the same. 10630 maybe a bit less sharp. lets say its a hair smoother.
had the re-connection problem too, switching modes. simple power cycle fixed it
I measured static RMS voltage output noise output of each firmware version with a test motor. Conditions: TBW=1000Hz, SimuCUBE mode, all settings constant during the test, motor idling without torque or rotation.
Results are:
It looks like .30 and .90 versions have practically same RMS noise level, which is expected result as filtering method was not changed between the versions.
cool results, i never went back to 1.6.1. but i recall a big difference in static hiss between the new ones.
(no need to go back to 1.6.1 
the last two betaâs are better than that one )
where did you measure the noise? at different parts on the wheel or the middle ? i measures the nosiest part with the wheel a bit too the left. ( 11 o clock aprrox )
Just a silly question. What is the real difference in feeling between unlimited and 1000hz tbw?
I know i know the official answer that higher hz is sharper lower can be smoother but we can have some lag or loose some kind of details but anyway is there anything which i feel e.g. in iracing or assetto between the two modes?
unlimited is smoother feedback for me its a clearly noticeable difference between the two in iracing.
i would say the higher the smoother 1000hz still feels sharp. i would advise everyone to try and run unlimited.
(you must try it with 10630 or 10690 beta ioni firmware dough)
It is a low-pass filter, which by definition smooths out the signal, allowing lower frequency signals to pass the filter. Unlimited disables the filter. The latency of this filter is negligible for simulator use case.
The other thing i do not understand is in simucube. The center frequency, attenuation and q facotr. I read the description but the question here is the same what should i feel if i set it correctly and what should i feel if it is totally wrong. I tried different settings but iam clueless.
Motor was just in the default angle after phasing. Itâs true that static noise does vary little bit depending on angle.
PS. glad to hear that the new FW works for you 
Iâm looking forward to perfect it for all motor types out there.
Noise levels for 1.6.90 1.6.30 and 1.6.01
So its definitely a positive improvement in the right directions 
Iâve been driving the Porsche around road Atlanta for a couple of hours with 1.6.90, previously on 1.6.30 - I have not encountered any problems and to be honest I canât tell the difference between the versions. My small mige and 10k encoder feel great - a big thanks to Mika, Tero and the team of testers for making my osw better and better.
Here is my Comparison on my small mige 10.000ppr
(11 O Clock is the noisiest point in my wheel)
full dataset download https://www.dropbox.com/s/e6nx2kzs3zoh86o/firmware%20compare%20all%20runs.rar?dl=0
It might be interesting to have some sort of ffb test in granity with the wheel moving left and right or something. so we can see what it does during actual movements / ffb signals
@Tero : Like @Mika said, with my Hirden 2500CPR sound in my steering wheel with the last IONI firmware 1.6.9 and the IONI damper. More damper, more lound sound⌠Change torque bandwitch number doesnât change anything.
With 1.6.3, no problem. Perfect Damping.
I never use any damping, but i tested it now and i too have to report that it sounds like searching for a radio channel.
When you turn the wheel now and when you put damper even higher it sounds like a old arcade game. didnât have that problem in 10630 either.
my gopro mic doesnt pic it up that well but its pretty loud.
ioni 10690 beta firmware damper sound
Friction and inertia damping seem oke.
I get a squeaky noise with dampening but only above 1.0. Friction doesnât produce any sound
Mige Sincos 2M encoder
